Carroll & Vincent Real Estate
508-627-0286 · carrollandvincent.com

119 Old Thumb Point Road, West Tisbury New Listing

$2,735,000

Beautifully sited on a knoll overlooking Deep Bottom Cove is a simple, yet totally charming, three season cottage with wonderful, protected water views and pond frontage. The cottage has seen some loving changes over the past 3 years: a dreamy screened porch has been added that the owner often uses as a sleeping porch; the beautiful, original wood floors have been restored; the galley kitchen has been brought into the 21st century; heat/ac has been added in the form of a “split”, an on-demand hot water heater now takes care of your domestic hot water needs and a new stack washer/drying has been installed. The setting is sublime – an unspoiled 3+ acres from which to explore the many coves of Tisbury Great Pond, the Pond itself and, of course, the barrier beach beyond. Sail, kayak, paddle board or putter around the Pond’s 800 acres or out to the sandy beach and the ocean beyond. If a sanctuary is what you are seeking, you will not want to miss visiting this cherished property.

Enter into the cottage from the front door. The living/dining room is to the left with wonderful views of Deep Bottom Cove out through the big picture window. To the right of the door is the partially updated gallery kitchen with a bank of new cabinets and a stone countertop. The bedroom is "behind" the kitchen; while beyond the dining area is the 2023 screened porch from which there are sublime views of the cove in two directions.
None.
Ample

More listings in West Tisbury

Data last updated: 09/22/2026. Some properties may no longer be for sale if they have gone under contract, have sold, or are no longer being offered for sale since the last update. Listed by Feiner Real Estate© 2026 LINK, All Rights Reserved. LINK does not warrant the accuracy, reliability or completeness of this information.