10 Danls Way, West Tisbury

Historic West Tisbury farmhouse with detached guest cottage on 1.27 acres in the heart of West Tisbury. Just moments from Alley’s General Store, 7a Foods, North Tisbury Village, and a short drive to beaches and both up- and downd Island destinations. This property presents a rare opportunity for a family compound, multi-generational living, or investment with rental income potential.

The four-bedroom main house blends timeless Vineyard character with modern comfort, featuring a vaulted kitchen with center island, Verona gas range, walk-in pantry, exposed beams, wide pine floors, period details, and two brick fireplaces. A flexible floor plan includes three first-floor bedrooms, with a private primary suite occupying the second level.

Set privately at the rear of the property, the detached one-bedroom guest cottage offers its own parking, yard, spacious deck, outdoor shower, loft, and open living area—ideal for guests, extended family, or income-producing rentals.

Expansive lawns provide ample space for entertaining, gardening, and enjoying the Vineyard lifestyle. Both homes have passed Title V septic inspections.

Enjoy as is or reenvision to make your own Martha’s Vineyard Farmhouse / Family Compound a reality.

First Floor

3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, living room, sitting area dining area, kitchen laundry/ pantry

Second Floor

One bedroom, one bathroom with a tub

Basement

Partial Block part stone, part crawl

Parking

yes

Other Buildings

Guest Cottage: 1 bedroom 1 bath, Garage//Workshop, Garden Shed and Storage Outbuilding

Second Dwelling

Income generating or multigenerational living. Single story 1-bed 1-bath cottage with open living dining area, loft, built in details, gas stove, wide pine flooring, outdoor shower. Set seperatly at the far end of the property with its own parking area, washer + dryer, electric + septic. Ready as is or for your future vision.