24 Pine Lane, West Tisbury New Listing

Set on a generous lot framed by mature landscaping, 24 Pine Lane offers four bedrooms across two distinct dwellings in a private, rural setting, yet in a surprisingly convenient location.
Lovingly built and maintained by a longtime Island family with decades of experience landscaping and caring for beautiful Island properties, the three-bedroom main residence features gorgeous pine floors, post-and-beam detailing, and distinctive cedar ceilings. A finished lower level with an air-exchange system provides additional flexible space, ideal for a home gym, recreation room, or other uses. A separate apartment at the garage adds a second living space and enhances the property’s versatility.
Thoughtful upgrades include solar, a reverse-osmosis drinking system, water filtration system, a backup generator that powers the apartment’s well during outages, and a 2024 roof. An outdoor wood-fired furnace provides heat and hot water to both dwellings, while the original oil and gas heating systems remain operational. A three-year firewood reserve is also included, offering significant potential heating-cost savings.
Two gardens, mature perimeter plantings, and generous room for vehicle parking add to the property’s privacy and versatility.
The apartment above the garage features radiant heat, a first-floor office, kitchen, washer and dryer, private deck, and outdoor shower. The deck wraps around a mature tree, creating a charming “treehouse” feel.
Each dwelling is served by its own 1,000-gallon septic system, with a three-bedroom design capacity per system. According to the West Tisbury Board of Health, the systems have a combined capacity to accommodate up to six bedrooms, subject to applicable zoning and permitting requirements.
A unique additional opportunity exists for an interested buyer to separately acquire the seller’s established Island landscaping business, including certain vehicles and equipment; details available upon request.
With solar power helping to keep electric costs low, radiant heat in the garage and apartment, two septic systems, generous parking, multiple work-from-home spaces, and a separate second dwelling, 24 Pine Lane offers a unique combination of character, practicality, and flexibility. Conveniently located for access to Vineyard Haven, Oak Bluffs, Edgartown, and Up-Island destinations.
Exclusions: Bertazzoni stove, clawfoot tub in the apartment. Owner occupied; 24-hour notice for showings.

First Floor

Kitchen, Mudroom, Living Room, Dining Room, Office, Bedroom, Common Bath.

Second Floor

Two Bedrooms, sitting room and a common bath

Basement

Finished with with utility, storage, flex space and home gym.

Parking

yes multiple vehicles

Other Buildings

Garage with Apartment, shed, Quonset huts (2)

Second Dwelling

The detached one-bay garage features a first-floor office and den, with a one-bedroom apartment above with a full kitchen, full bath with laundry, private deck, and outdoor shower. Propane-fired hot water and radiant heat. Separate 1000 gallon septic servicing this dwelling.