42 Marthas Road, Edgartown New Listing

A RARE KATAMA JEWEL BOX — TURNKEY LUXURY TODAY, WITH ROOM TO GROW.

In one of Edgartown’s most coveted enclaves, this beautifully reimagined three-bedroom, two-bath residence offers the ease of new construction with timeless Vineyard character. Taken down to the frame and rebuilt in 2024 by a hand-picked team of the Island’s finest builders and craftsmen, the home is essentially brand new — every system, every surface, every finish. And with room to expand to as many as six bedrooms*, it’s a turnkey retreat today and a signature compound tomorrow.

The home lives far larger than its footprint. Vaulted ceilings open the great room to the rafters, crowned by reclaimed beams milled from an 1800s Ohio barn and anchored by a classic brick fireplace. Wide-plank floors run throughout. Behind the new walls and vaulted ceilings: new spray foam insulation, all-new plumbing and electrical, and energy-efficient mini-splits for quiet heating and air conditioning.

The designer open and vaulted kitchen features quartz countertops, a brick backsplash, island seating and a full suite of new GE Café® appliances including an induction range. Both baths are newly finished in premium Italian tile with glass showers and radiant heated floors.

Glass doors open to an expansive deck with pergola and fire-pit table. Outside: low maintenance James Hardie® fiber cement siding, AZEK® trim, a welcoming front porch and generous off-street parking. Owners enjoy private association pickleball and tennis, with South Beach two miles away and downtown Edgartown.

Offered fully furnished and completely turnkey, with two years of rental history. An exceptional offering.
Please note: listing agent has an ownership interest in the property. Assessed value does not reflect the complete 2024 gut renovation.

First Floor

Features single-floor living

Second Floor

na

Basement

Full basement with a poured foundation, ready for expansion.

Parking

8 spaces